Thursday, August 11, 2011

The politics of the clothesline

Never thought I would witness this.  I mean, India is a land of contradictory realities and all that, but somehow, witnessing such an exchange never struck me as a possibility.

The centrally located, relatively new and decidedly yuppie residential complex in Mumbai that houses me, has a residents' Google list.  (And, I am certain, a Facebook page, some twitter ID, and whatever else is the yuppie thing to do nowadays)  On this Google list, there is a constant stream of emails from people listing their views on the community, issues of common interest, 'help wanted' ads for maids and drivers, and what have you.  All nice and neighbourly.  A recent email caught my attention.  Judging by the immediate burst of hubbub it created, I wasn't alone.

"I think it shouldn't be allowed," declared the writer, "for residents to dry their laundry on an external clothesline."

Now, if you have seen, passed by, lived in, any residential community anywhere in India, you know this much for a fact.  The clothesline is a birth-right.  We are the people the have hung our dirty laundry in public for all recorded history.  We are the people that crane their necks out of freshly rented apartments, trying to look for the tell-tale nails and hooks the previous occupant might have left behind.  We have a special kind of nylon rope that was invented for the sole purpose of becoming a clothesline.  I am pretty sure we invented that weird 'three poles triangulating' sort of arrangement that supports clotheslines in open areas.  We are, in short, clothesline people.  "I think it shouldn't be allowed for residents to dry their laundry on an external clothesline"??  Gasp!

"I agree", started the next email.  Wait a minute.  What?  You agree?

Turns out a lot of people agreed.

I am not the most observant of people, so maybe I had missed something all these days.  The next morning, I took a walk around, and looked up at all the balconies in our complex.  Sure enough, no clotheslines.  Except for the offending few that had so aggrieved our emailer.  I can see a blue towel fluttering away from the fifth floor.  A few ... let's say 'delicates' whose colors are indeterminate high up on the eighth floor.  Oh, and one of the offenders, blithely oblivious to the heated chatter about them and their ilk, has a brown bed-sheet hanging out there, in all its yellow floral glory.  Sweet!  But strip those out, and there isn't any other line in sight.  Hmm ...

There are two primary arguments for the 'No Clothesline' movement.  One is purely aesthetic.  'When I sit out on my balcony, I don't want to be staring at your well worn socks' so to speak.  Fair enough.  And the other argument, derived from the same, but one step removed, is economic.  Properties in clothesline strewn buildings lose value, goes this argument.  Clotheslines are for the tacky, the middle class, the old.  Add them anywhere near my apartment, and you are reducing my sale price.  I tried searching for some research that might establish this causal relationship, but no luck.

Electric clothes dryers have been around in the developed world since the 1940s.  By the late 50s and the 60s, they started to be really popular.  It started off, if I understand it right, as a symbol of affluence. 'I am successful, you can't see my underwear any more', in a manner of speaking.  Slowly, like with most household gadgets in the west, they became ubiquitous, and communities could scarcely recall a time when things had been different.  There were still the pesky few who might put their laundry out to dry.  But by now, every community had their own regulations barring such behaviour.

In India, needless to say, communities have had much bigger problems than the impact of sun-drying clothes on real estate prices.  Dryers were practically unknown and largely unavailable.  Electricity was expensive.  There wasn't much of a sense of personal space anyway, so the neighbour's clothesline blended right in to your life.  So the dear clothesline lived on.  Until now, it appears.

The average electric clothes dryer consumes energy at the rate of 4,000 Watts.  Yes, there is no decimal error here.  You read it right the first time.  It is probably the most energy guzzling domestic appliance invented by man, with the possible exception of central air-conditioning.  How much is 4,000 Watts?  Well, let us say you hang the clothes you want to dry on one of those standing clothes racks, place the rack in a room, and turn on a ceiling fan to dry things out ...  You can come back three days later, pick up your clothes and walk out of the room feeling all green, because you still saved some energy by not putting the clothes into a dryer.

"Why would I use the dryer?" my wife asks me, when the email debate comes up.  "It over-dries my clothes, fades out the colours, and is too expensive.  And all the while, I have this bright sun burning its energy out on my balcony, begging to be put to some use.  What a waste!"  That's true, I grant her, but there is something to the idea of not having to look at other people's laundry.  Call me a snob.

"I think everyone should be allowed to decide for themselves", someone bravely pipes in on the Google list finally.  "After all, this is India."  Attaboy!

It is early in the morning, and I am walking my daughter to her school bus.  We are walking past the building that started off the fiery debate.  I look up.  An old lady, sari all crumpled from a night's sleep is out on the balcony.  She is moving slowly, her hands are full, and she is straining with the effort.  Slowly, she is pulling off her clothesline the brown bedsheet, with its yellow floral print.  She pulls it all the way off, and concentrating hard, flips it over, hangs it back out.  She fastens it in place with a couple of clips, straightens her back slowly, takes in the view outside, turns, and trudges slowly back inside, ready to start the rest of her day.

For a moment there, she looked like my mother.

14 comments:

  1. it is amusing to see this debate , i used to think that for all the hot air abt environmental consciousness in the west their refusal to apply perfectly easy & common sense third world solutions to energy conservation was such hypocrisy...now it seems we have become affluent enough to go the other way :)

    ReplyDelete
  2. I actually have a clothesline in my backyard here in the US. Yes, I do have a backyard so none other than my family sees it, but I agree with your wife in using the energy that's out there. I routinely air dry my swim outfits n towels, etc rather than running the dryer.

    The problem my parents face where they live is something different. The clotheslines are outside the balcony (covered area), so if the people living above them hang dripping clothes, then all that water falls on our clothes. During monsoons and winter, the laundry takes a while to dry, and this is an issue. Also no one likes other people's laundry water to drop on theirs. It's a saga that goes on but people just deal with it.

    I hope the clothesline doesn't go away. I like how our Indian lifestyle is in so many ways....and the good parts don't need to change.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Apart from clothesline, another "not-so-yuppie" thing that may hurt home values in Mumbai is the greyish rusty metal grills that they put on everything where Air can seep through ... the balcony, the door, the windows, even the small bathroom window.

    Imagine the multiplying impact when the buyer sees the grills, and the clothesline, in the middle of a cloudy day in the monsoon season

    ReplyDelete
  4. Turns out driers aren't that common in London and many Londoners like to use clotheslines even if they do possess driers.

    We looked long and hard to find a house with a drier, but as it turns out we find ourselves using a clothesline more often than not. The only difference is, we would never dream of hanging our clothes out in the balcony. It rains all the time. :P

    ReplyDelete
  5. This article reminded me of how my life has improved over the years, at least in this aspect :).

    My earliest personal experience was when the clothesline was inside my hostel room! The extra moisture this added to the already high humidity in Chennai was not pleasant. Then I moved to Mumbai where the clothesline was outside in the balcony, reducing its impact from physical discomfort to an eye sore. Then came the move to the West with its abundant supply of dryers and electricity.

    At the risk of attracting flames, let me say this- I love not having to deal with the clothesline anymore. Energy conservation be damned!

    ReplyDelete
  6. Loved this post. And I love clotheslines.

    Though I dry clothes inside my house on a clothes - drying - rack (with the fan on during the monsoon months), that's only because there are too many pigeons around that sit on anything you hang outside and pee-poo on it. Not on my freshly washed clothes !

    I actually like looking up at buildings that have lots of clothes hanging outside - it makes for such a colourful mosaic. Next time you are on the highway, look at all the houses some distance away and tell me that the clothes hanging there do not add to their friendly appeal.

    Zen

    ReplyDelete
  7. p.s Also, am going to copy this post on to my blogs sometime. Please say 'no' if you have any objection.

    Zen

    ReplyDelete
  8. Since my parents moved out of my childhood home in a small town in 1989, my mother has had to get increasingly more clever about hanging her clothes out so that she doesn't run afoul of the neighborhood association rule prohibiting clothes lines. She now lives in hot, dry Arizona where wet clothes dry in about 30 seconds. But she has to hide her hanging clothes behind a retractable bamboo screen on the porch so the neighbors don't report her.

    ReplyDelete
  9. @ Thomas - See, it seems like such a shame that in Arizona, with the blazing sun is wasting itself outside, households would have driers running indoors. Just doesn't seem to make sense! Tip of the hat to your mother!

    ReplyDelete
  10. @ entropy - Wow, you are really taking the fight right up to the opposition aren't you? Making the argument that clotheslines are actually aesthetically appealing ... now that is a brave argument.

    ReplyDelete
  11. But it is, JS. Forget the pseudness involved and just look at all the colours. It's like looking down on Chowpatty on a day when it's crowded, so many colours, all mingling together.

    What to do, I am like this only. Fully gaonti.

    Zen

    ReplyDelete
  12. Clothesline is still okay but what when the wind blows away the CLOTHES (damn...they are expensive) off the LINES..!! or u find some pigeon sitting on them after a heavy meal...!!! I hate it personally but do we have many options??

    ReplyDelete
  13. This is one problem we need to solve in housing ..as we have balconies as extended breathing and living spaces.. Builders who build these apartments and club house ..could do justice to think about this problem .provide for common washing , drying spaces and add them with ironing facilities ..to give employment to few young boys to earn a living ..

    I really liked your blog.. Would like to use while talking to builders ..as problem to solve..while balancing Eco friendly ways of washing , drying clothes..

    TG

    ReplyDelete